The Pot, Calling the Kettle Black

20160101_080421_resized

Something that I have seen over the past few years that gives me a good laugh is, yup, the pot calling the kettle black. Maybe it’s not the best of idioms to use here, but let me explain what I mean here in a minute. This has been, and is,  quite a talked about topic in the Bushcraft and Survival communities. You can find it all over peoples blogs and even some websites ran by the “experts”. Not only can you find it in those places, but you can typically see it across social media on all levels by some of their followers, that stand fast on their guru being the only one who could be qualified.

So the topic you ask? It is people wanting to know what other’s credentials are with regards to teaching. Maybe more specifically, what qualifies them to be teaching Bushcraft or Survival skills. It seems nowadays, that if you haven’t been on television, or written a few books, that you couldn’t possibly have what it takes to teach this stuff. The television folks really crack me up. Get a bit of publicity, and they are somehow the voice and pinnacle of “Qualified Instructors”. To be put on television, and in most cases, in a scripted scenario, hardly makes you qualified in my book. Even if the scenarios are not scripted, it is still television and is strategically and professionally edited to get the intended outcome, drama. So do One thing cool, and you are an expert! The world probably didn’t see all the nonsense that was edited out. Now I’m not taking away from the fact that there have been some good shows, I like to watch them too. And some of these folks are pretty crafty and entertaining, but qualified to teach, or experts? I would beg to differ…..but that’s just me. I would say that makes them, at a minimum a celebrity perhaps, not the authority on teaching.

Upon leaving the TV scene, some of these folks have created schools, and profess to be the voice and reason of the two communities. Maybe they had schools before TV, though not hardly as successful as they would like you to believe, I can assure you. So now they have the public eye, and pitch to everyone how they are more qualified to teach this stuff than anyone else. Yet, they started just like everyone else. Their television experience has somehow put them at a higher level than you. While you were living it, doing research perhaps, practicing in the field and so on, they became far more experienced by shooting a television show? Again, I would tend to think otherwise, but that’s just me.

Writing a few books gets somewhat of the same effect as the television scene, though obviously not as much. So writing about your experiences, or doing research to write your own conglomeration of things also makes you an “expert”, or better than everyone else with regards, again, to teaching this stuff? Because you have written about the topics, makes your credentials to teach it, greater? I would tend to disagree here as well. I would say that makes you a writer, not the authority on teaching.

Newsflash, being on television or having written your own books does not make you a teacher or an authority on the matter when it comes to teaching Bushcraft or Survival skills. Being able to teach folks, in a way that allows them to grasp the information, and in such a way that they can then use it, or even teach it themselves, makes you a good teacher. Adding in that the information is relevant, accurate and promotes safety, would also be good to note.

So why does this happen? Well, there are a lot of reasons for this, but here are a few. Monetary competition, ego, marketing and the likes all play a big part in this, as well as trying to be the best out there (which is not entirely bad, but is when you have to knock others to try and do so). Being a “Legend” or “Expert”, aren’t tags that you can ever give yourself, they are given to you by others.

So I guess the short of the long is, worry about yourself and not what others are doing, or trying to do (wise words by my Mom some years ago). Don’t feel the need to bash or belittle other schools or folks for trying to do what you do, because you started out just like they did. I know a gentlemen who has done all of the above with regards to TV, books, has a Masters degree in education and more, but you never hear of any of that from him, and he has been successful for the last couple of decades, far longer than any of the newer, self-proclaimed experts.

Rant complete.

Here is a great article that is worth your time and goes along with this pretty well: http://www.jackmtn.com/simplog/living-the-life/

 

 

 

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “The Pot, Calling the Kettle Black

  1. Excellent description of today’s “Master expert guru woodsman”. What TV show you starred in or what great book you wrote does not a bushcrafter make. Masters of BS is more like it in most cases. The ones who are self promoters that don’t care who they “borrow” from to claim as their own give the illusion of greatness. A true teacher is humble and teaches for the satisfaction of teaching, in my opinion, not for fame and recognition. I understand people making a living at a skill or craft but never at the expense of others or building a reputation on self made greatness. There are names for those types of folks, they are called con artists, charlatans, carpet baggers, snake oil salesmen, etc…Sad to see that in a time where information and learning resources are literally at a person’s fingertips that some people can’t see through it…

    Liked by 1 person

  2. There’s a lot I could say here but those in the know have already have enlightened me & for that I’m truly grateful (you know who you are) so I won’t air dirty laundry here. With this in mind all I will say is ignore all the hype, chest beating & gizmos Put the time in yourself out in the field to hone your skills, it’s the only way to make them yours. Seek advice & learning material from credible sources, you should be able to see a fraud a mile off these days!
    TV will only give you half baked ideas & ultimately teaches nothing but to live with disappointment, trust me I know & that’s why I changed tact!
    Finally if your on this page then your already in good place to gain expert knowledge & learn useful skills without all the BS that unfortunately appears to have found its way into a once tight & true community…..

    Like

  3. True observations of most “Guru’s” perceived notions of themselves. As a certified instructor, my only goal is to present information in such a way as to make it memorable and useful to others. What’s the use of keeping all the knowledg to yourself? We will all be gone one day. It is my desire to pass on the torch so that others may continue to see the light. It’s all about what you leave behind. My hope is always to have inspired my students to do their best with the hope of them learning something new. I tell them to take what’s useful and discard the rest. It’s never been how people serve me but rather how I can serve them. Titles are the same as toilet paper. I agree with your comments.

    Like

  4. LOL i’m pretty sure no one in the “Community” are creating anything new. They are teaching and displaying skills and techniques that were developed over years of use. No one is coming up with anything that hasn’t been tried before out of necessity. What i find the most important factor is the person themselves, the Teacher so-to-speak. What works for me may not work for you and someone who can teach me may not resonate with the next guy. Sometimes flash-in-the-pan instructors appear only to fade away once whats under the candy shell is exposed. I look for the guy plodding along in the shadows who makes sense, isn’t arrogant, and allows/demands fieldwork. You cant always buy skills on thier online store.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s